You’re doing it all wrong. Here’s the right way to store butter

Butter is a staple in many households, yet the way we store it often leads to a compromise in its flavor and texture. A common sight is butter wrapped in its original packaging, tucked away in the corner of a refrigerator door or left out on a counter, exposed to air and odors. These practices not only affect the taste of the butter but can also lead to spoilage far sooner than necessary.
Understanding the correct methods for storing butter can significantly extend its shelf life and preserve its rich, creamy texture. Whether you’re a casual baker or someone who enjoys butter on toast every morning, knowing how to store your butter properly can enhance your culinary experiences and keep your butter fresh for longer.
1. The Importance of Proper Butter Storage
Proper butter storage is crucial to maintain its quality and taste. Butter is made up of fat, water, and milk solids, which can be affected by exposure to air, light, and strong odors. When left uncovered, butter can quickly absorb flavors from surrounding foods, leading to an unpleasant taste. Furthermore, exposure to air can result in oxidation, causing the butter to become rancid. Ideally, butter should be stored in a cool, dark place to prevent these issues.
Temperature is another important factor in butter storage. Butter should be kept at a consistent temperature to prevent it from melting and refreezing, which can alter its texture. The ideal storage temperature for butter is between 32°F to 35°F (0°C to 1.6°C) in the refrigerator. However, for immediate use, keeping butter at room temperature is acceptable, provided it is consumed within a few days.
2. Keeping Butter Out of the Fridge for Daily Use
For those who use butter regularly, storing it outside the fridge can be convenient and improve its spreadability. When kept at room temperature, butter remains soft and easy to spread, which is ideal for applications like bread or toast. However, to prevent spoilage, it is recommended to keep only a small amount of butter out at a time, typically enough for one or two days of use.
Using a butter dish with a cover is essential when storing butter at room temperature. This protects the butter from air and contaminants, maintaining its freshness. It’s important to place the butter dish away from direct sunlight and heat sources, which can cause the butter to melt and spoil.

see next page